Image Credit: Michael Becker/Fox“This is certainly under the radar,” Ryan Seacrest quipped as he announced in front of thousands of screaming wanna-be singers at the Los Angeles auditions today that Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler will join Randy Jackson on the American Idol panel. Fox treated the unveiling at The Forum in Inglewood, Calif. as if it wasn’t the worst-kept secret in Hollywood; Lopez, in particular, was unveiled like a veritable demi-God by appearing on a raised platform amid a cloud of smoke. Truly, the only surprising news to come out of today’s announcement was that Jackson will be the new “anchor of the panel.” (Okay, J. Lo’s sparkly jumpsuit was kinda surprising, too.)
The new judges seemed as happy as if they just won the lottery. Joined on a dais with executive producers Nigel Lythgoe and Ken Warwick, along with Seacrest, Jackson, Fox reality exec Mike Darnell and record executive Jimmy Iovine, Tyler and Lopez admitted to being longtime fans of the 10-year-old talent show. “I always loved watching the outcome on Idol, the kids crying and screaming,” said the Aerosmith frontman. “It resonates with my career and where it now.”
“I’m a huge fan,” added Lopez. “I kind of raised my eyebrows [when I was first approached about the gig], but my career has always been the type that changes and evolves.”
In addition to joining the show, Lopez was also rewarded a first-look deal with Fox Films and Fox Broadcasting Co. The singer-actress brushed off reports that her “diva demands” caused delays in the finalization of her Idol deal. “I’m kind of used to the [negative press],” Lopez said. “After as many years as I’ve been doing this, I’m used to it. I was calming the Fox people down, telling them ‘It will be gone tomorrow. It’s going to be fine! We know what the truth!’ I was looking forward to getting started.”
“There was so much rubbish out there,” said Lythgoe. “We heard she only liked yellow M & Ms! There are so many stories.” Fox’s Darnell also chimed in: “The deal was not tough. There were no diva demands. It was easy and comfortable. It was all about schedule and dates! They were typical deals, to be frank.”
Tyler, meanwhile, faced some troubling times with his fellow band members when the press began speculating that he was in the running for a seat at the judges’ table. “At first, they were jealous,” said the singer. “They heard it through the press and not from me. But four months ago they were looking for another lead singer. I spent a stint in Betty Ford. They have been judging me every day, and sometimes it hurt, but most times I came out through the worm hole a stronger person. It’s a real journey with those guys. And they would say the same about me. I’m sure they are real happy for me.”
First and foremost: Don’t expect anyone on the new panel to assume the role of King Crankypants, left vacant by Simon Cowell. “I don’t know whether there will be a replacement,” Jackson said. “We all have our moments of toughness and nurturing and sweetness.”
“I believe in tough love but I don’t think I can ever be cruel to another artist,” added Lopez. “There are definitely better ways to say things.”
Lythgoe also promised some changes in the new season. Contestants won’t be asked to step out of their comfort zones: Country singers, for example, will get to stick with what they do best. The participants will also perform songs from certain decades, not from particular artists (so long, Elvis night!). “We are looking to bring artists along and really give them some input,” said Iovine, who will serve as a mentor. “We’re looking for originality. We are not looking for singers like Whitney Houston, but those who were influenced by Whitney Houston and bring their own stuff to the game. They can’t just be told to sing better, someone has to work with them on performance and style.”
Lythgoe also left open the possibility of guest judges joining the panel (Elton John, now’s your chance!). “We have three we are happy with,” he said, “but we’re always open to anybody else if they want to come along and we feel they add to this.” The EP also admitted that he’s glad the endless speculation about about Idol‘s new judging panel is finally over. “I don’t want the judges worrying about ratings. They have to worry about the talent. Thank goodness this happened today so we can put the focus back on the kids. What we’ve got to worry about is moving forward, not about Simon not being here. We have a great legacy from the past, but now we have to talk about the future.”










I’m so excited about Steven being a judge! This is going to be a great memory for him. Steven definitely has a lot of passion, he will love this job.
Does he still have a functioning memory?
I think that zombies retain at least some of their base memories.
Yay for Steven! Very fun man!
S Tyler is just so hard to look at. Enough to make me stop watching
I said the EXACT same thing to my co-worker after looking at his pic on the front page….YIKES!
let’s hope he can stay sober enough to last the season…
If it worked for Paula, I think he’ll be fine.
I cant’wait to watch this!
by the way by accepting thsi J-Lo has officially dead for the music industry!
Steven Tyler? I love him! he rocks!!!!!!!!!
I am sorry I meant to write SHE HAS OFICIALLY BEEN DECLARED DEAD for the MUSIC INDUSTRY! she is now a has been….ACTUALLY SHE WAS VERY SUCCESFULL…..
Steven Tyler THE BEST PICK!
Like she needs the music industry anymore. She is a millionaire, ad she is married to Marc Anthony, another millionaire, pardon me, multi-millionaires.
She may be a millionaire, but she needs the $$$ to keep up with her lavish lifestyle, so SHE NEEDS WORK!!!
And she is clearly the bread winner of the two.
Steven the rock legend with the unique voice is clearly the winner that has the potential to help contestants be a huge star. Not JLO!
So why is her career “declared dead” but he is “the best pick”? You sexist jerk, can’t you see they are both DOA by working for this corporate cabal of banality? They both used to be relevant, now they are has-beens. Yawn. So glad to have my Tuesday/Wednesday nights back. I’ll still read Slezak, though; he’s funny.
Do you know how to EMPHASIZE your POINT? Put random words in ALL CAPS. IT REALLY WORKS!!
On topic, I don’t think her career is dead. She’s always been working in different parts of the entertainment industry. My only question is, why can’t we have a panel on a reality show that is mostly female?
Oh good, no more theme nights/forcing contestants to expand beyond their genre! No more “Stuff Like That There”, “Summertime”, “Alone”, “Over the Rainbow”, “Always Be My Baby”, “Tracks of My Tears” or “Heartless”. Whew. What a relief.
Oh Theme Weeks, I think I’ll miss you most of all!
Awesome post, Joslyn. You’re a true fan.
The show will not be the number one show next year, after a curiosity rating spike the show will slowly start sliding in the ratings, not anybodies fault just a tired show. And they kept the worse possible judge, seriously Randy Jackson should be judging pie contests.
format change? great to see the elimination of some of the most repeated material, BUT does this mean contestants will not be challenged by different formats & genre?
I knew this show was done when Simon left. Steven Tyler? Jennifer Lopez? Horrible!! I’ll be checking out Xfactor instead
OK that’s settled. Now fix the unlimited text voting issue. Until they change that, be prepared for nothing but talentless cute guys to win.
Agreed.
Ditto!
Exactly. America’s got talent has a limited voting method, but the final winner this past season still fell into the same type / category. Thus, I don’t know if it’ll help.
I am sure for someone liek J-Lo is not good enough being millionaire..I cut my hand she would die for having the success she had back in 2001!
a) j lo entrance was laughable. what adiss to steven tyler ALREADY. granted, he probably didn’t want a big thing, and she of course, DID
b) i completely belive the diva demands speculation. what other judge has had a first look with fox films clause. total pain in the giant j lo.
c) randy jackson is the anchor judge….wiat. WHAT DID THEY JUST SAY?…bahahahahahahahahahahahaha!
d) allowing the contestants to stay in their genre? should have happened years ago. the only smart thing to come out of today.
thank you
The worst thing about Steven Tyler as Judge on AI will be seeing his face in HD.
The worst thing about Steven Tyler being a judge on AI is Steven Tyler being a judge on AI.
Didn’t Nigel Lythgoe say ages ago that he wanted to make American Idol all about the contestants again – and not about the judges? LOL…too funny Nigel (liar)
Well, that settles it. Guess I’ll be finding some other way to spend 2 hours a week. Jello and Tyler actually make Kara and Ellen look good.
VIVA LA LOPEZ !!!!!!
fix your website! It’s not posting!
So Jimmy Iovine is playing the Tim Gunn role for American Idol 4.0? Intriguing…