'American Idol' exit Q&A: Pia Toscano tears up while discussing her 'amazing memories' from the show -- EXCLUSIVE VIDEO

An emotional Pia Toscano, the 22-year-old New Yorker who was shockingly eliminated from American Idol Thursday night, said she had a feeling bad news might […] Read the full post.

Comments (304 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 11
  • Frank

    Personally, I believe it to be extremely Political! With the “Election” coming Up, I believe it was the perfect time to influence the Black/Latino Vote! What a Shame! J-LO’S A FAKE! They all Knew! GOD BLESS YOU PIA! STAY STRONG!

  • Dave

    Totally agree… a Johnny Cash massacre from Paul…. but really, Lauren and Hailey are worth watching… (and listening to too!) KEEEEEEEUTE!

  • Musiqluvr

    Why is everyone in denial!?!? American Idol has been losing credibility for years. No female contestant can win again. The unlimited teeny bopper votes will not allow that especially so long as a cute talented teenage boy is in the competition. If Tim Urban was actually talented he would have won the whole competition last year. Grown-ups should probably tune into the voice or x-factor who I’m sure will have voting limits. 10 years invested in AI and now I’m done after this season.

  • Frank


  • Sher Atkin

    Pia is a lovely girl and a great singer, but I don’t see her as a recording artist, which is what you need. Not a voice that you would hear on the radio and say, heh that is Pia. She definately will have a career in music despite being voted out. Now Scotty is a guy who could cut a record right now and sell millions of records. Good luck to you all.

    • Maryann Russo

      I agree with you 100%

      • Danielle

        Me too. And I don’t do country.

  • Avery Philip

    For me you were the best singer on the show. Writing you all the way from St. Lucia down in the Caribbean. I looked forward to hear you sing every week. This is a blessing for you cause the whole worl knows that you can sing. Now you have more time to advance your career and you have a head start. Class act, and you sang so well even though you were crying, Amazing

  • whatashow

    I have watched Idol since Season 1 — and Now I am done.
    The teeny boppers have destroyed the show.
    I won’t even bother to watch the rest of this season. Who cares — the girls will go before Stefano and Jacob. I can’t watch this teeny bopper show anymore. The producers should have changed the voting rules seasons ago when the teeny boppers got cell phones.

  • Mike

    Face it – she was the LEAST popular out of 13 people. 13 !! She’s not that as great as you think she is

    • Raquel

      I think your tone deaf…. Vocal talent…. she blows them all away. They are not even in the same league. She is better than American Idol and like all the others before her that got voted off, I guarantee she will be on the charts for years to come.

  • nancy moreno

    PIA can be a model and sing on a cruise ship (she had no stage presence or SPARK) i have been rooting for JAMES/SCOTTY

  • Phil

    It’s the judges fault. They used their save on Casey – What a waste. Casey should have been gone long ago.

  • raja

    pia is a class act, she was and is still the best there is. She has a great future ahead.

  • JJ

    It really doesn’t matter who is the best. It’s not a singing competition, its a popularity contest. So, Scotty will take it.

  • Raquel

    I remember when Celine Dion started out… she has an incredible voice but needed to work on her performance and look where she is now. Pia has that same vocal talent and with perseverance she too can be where Celine Dion is…. That’s talent. Good Luck Pia.

  • Britney

    I believe that Pia should not have been voted off but Jacob Lusk is currently the one to beat,but hey after last nights votes, no one is safe.

  • Doris

    Outrageous!!!!!!!!! America you got it WRONG!! here in Barbados we think that she is the TOTAL package!!! BRING HER BACK!!

    • Britney

      Amen Sista we barbadians say she was in it to win it.BRING HER BACK BRING HER BACK!

      • jeanette


Page: 1 2 3 4 5 11
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.


Latest Videos in TV

From Our Partners

TV Recaps